North Yorkshire Council disputes road funding decision with legal challenge

North Yorkshire Council has initiated legal proceedings against the York and North Yorkshire Combined Authority (CA), arguing that a recent funding decision could leave the county facing a £20m shortfall for road maintenance.
Leaders of the unitary authority are pursuing a judicial review after the CA approved its Transport Capital Programme for 2026–2030 without their support.
The proposal received backing from Mayor David Skaith and representatives from City of York Council. However, North Yorkshire Council leader Carl Les and deputy leader Gareth Dadd opposed the plans.
Council leaders have raised concerns that additional government funding has been “top-sliced” by the mayor to support other transport initiatives. They also object to a revised funding formula that would see around £4m redirected from North Yorkshire’s allocation to City of York Council.
In a formal pre-action letter sent by assistant chief executive Barry Khan, the authority claims the decision—made on 27 March—was affected by legal errors, rendering it unlawful. The letter notes that the council does not take such action “lightly”.
However, it adds: “It is important for CA that the issues contained in this letter are taken seriously and also assists in setting how the partner organisations work in the future.
“It is hoped that this can be used to reset relationships and ensure that we can all work collaboratively for our residents in the future.”
It continues: “This letter is therefore sent – urgently – expressly as a transparent attempt to alert the CA to the clear legal errors that occurred and provide the opportunity for them to be corrected by the suspended implementation of the decision and the re-taking of the decision in a lawful manner.
“This will avoid the worst case scenario – for all parties – of a judicial review being brought with the associated cost, time and poor optics of litigation.
“The public purse is not best served in taking legal proceedings in this matter if it can be resolved by other means.”
The council argues that the decision required the agreement of its leader and also alleges that procedural rules were breached when an amendment to the budget proposal was not allowed.
Cllr Les said the move was necessary as the outcome was “prejudicial to the residents of North Yorkshire”.
He added: “The basis of setting up the combined authority was that, although it had been led by the mayor, it requires a great deal of consensus to move initiatives or to deliver initiatives.
“We think this is a budgetary matter and, under the constitution, the budget has to be not only a majority opinion of the authority, but it’s got to be a unanimous decision by the authority, so there are elements in the decision-making that we think are flawed.”
Responding to the challenge, Mr Skaith described the action as “beyond regrettable”.
He added: “It’s a political stunt which could waste thousands and thousands of pounds of taxpayer money. I think the public will see it for what it is, the Tories using public money to fight against getting more investment every year for the next four years.
“That record investment will now have to be paused. That stings so much because they sat back quietly when the last Conservative government actually did cut their roads funding two years in a row.
“I wasn’t elected to carry on the business as usual that has failed communities across North Yorkshire for decades.”
Alongside the legal action, the council has also asked its transport, economy, environment and enterprise scrutiny committee to review the decision-making process behind the budget.
Explore more: Visit our Local Authorities section for comprehensive coverage of UK council highways projects. Updates on local authority procurement, frameworks, funding, and regional road maintenance.
In this story North Yorkshire Council, City of York Council



















